INDIAN MUSIC FORUM ARCHIVES: Tabla Forum: who's better Zakir, Anindo, or Shawn Mativetsky ????

 

Author Message
ron h
who's better Zakir, Anindo, or Shawn Mativetsky ???? Apr 20, 2004 03:54 p.m.


being new to tabla i have just heard shawn a few months back. his sound is very good. just wondering where he ranks compared to Zakir and Anindo. I have not heard them live but i am sure that Mr. Mativetsky is at the least in the same league Thoughts?

montreal rules!

HaHa
Re:who's better Zakir, Anindo, or Shawn Mativetsky ???? Apr 20, 2004 04:44 p.m.


HaHa Ha Ha!!!

Interesting....

TRKTDHA
Re:who's better Zakir, Anindo, or Shawn Mativetsky ???? Apr 21, 2004 05:52 p.m.


Similar postings showed up earlier, road, check the old postings ...
Shawn
Re:who's better Zakir, Anindo, or Shawn Mativetsky ???? Apr 23, 2004 09:12 a.m.


Hi all,

Ron, I really hope you're joking... firstly, the question of "who's better" in tabla is a question that comes up often, but that really has no answer because it's a matter of personal taste, style, etc...

But in this case, I can definitely say that Zakirji and Anindoji are better tabla players than me! Though, they play different styles, they're both years (many!) ahead of me in practice and experience. I can only hope to one day reach their level of playing. I have to say that I'm a bit disturbed that you would even use my name in the same sentence as these two other players. These are two masters of tabla playing and I'm still very much a student. (Though I do teach and play professionally in Montreal.) I thank you for the compliment to my playing, but I really do not deserve to be compared to these master players.

I just want to note, however, that while I think that both are great tabla players, neither are my role models for tabla playing. That would have to be my Guruji - Pandit Sharda Sahai-ji of the Benares gharana.

Learning tabla is a lifetime process...

Take care,


Shawn
http://www.percussionist.net
joe
Re:who's better Zakir, Anindo, or Shawn Mativetsky ???? Apr 28, 2004 02:02 a.m.


Ok shawn. Now im interested in hearing you play. Can you post a sound clip of you playing on your website
[Previous] [Up] [Next]

SPONSORED LINKS